Black Rose Cream Mask
Sisley-Paris
Product Verdict Card
Sisley-Paris
Black Rose Cream Mask
mask
Consumer product research based on available product data, ingredients, pricing, and AI analysis. Not skin guidance.
Glow Score
Review tradeoffs first
Formula
Formula read is mixed; compare value before reading the score as a simple yes/no.
Fit flags
Fit is the main watch item; review the ingredient list and compare similar mask options.
Value
Value is a caution flag; the score needs to justify the $270 price.
Compare this against other mask products before buying — especially if price, texture, or ingredient fit matters for you.
Glow Index summary
AI skincare analysis for Sisley-Paris Black Rose Cream Mask
Glow Index analyzed Sisley-Paris Black Rose Cream Mask as a mask using a 4-model AI skincare research process. It currently scores 43/100, with the strongest signals coming from ingredient efficacy, safety profile, formula transparency.
Use this page as a product research snapshot: compare the formula/value signals, read the model reasoning, then review the broader mask rankings before deciding whether the product fits your preferences and budget.
Glow Index is a consumer research tool, not medical advice. Scores are based on product information and AI analysis of ingredients, pricing, evidence, and marketing claims. Patch test new products and consult a qualified professional for skin conditions or medical concerns.
Skip It
Our AI panel found this product underdelivers for the price.
Quick Take
Skip it. Better options exist.
Pros
- Shea butter, squalane, glycerin, and panthenol form a genuinely functional moisturizing base that delivers real short-term softness and temporary plumpness.
- All hero botanical actives (Black Rose, Padina Pavonica, Physalis Alkekengi, Grape Leaf) appear late in the INCI list, indicating trace-level concentrations with no clinical evidence of efficacy at those doses.
- Jar packaging accelerates oxidation of tocopheryl acetate and any unstable plant antioxidants, eroding even the modest efficacy these ingredients might offer over time.
- High levels of shea butter, squalane and glycerin give an immediate, cushiony moisture surge.
Cons
- Fragrance allergens including citronellol and geraniol (from Rosa Hybrid Flower Extract and Michelia Alba Leaf Oil) are present — confirmed user reports of burning, prolonged redness, and cystic acne breakouts across multiple sources.
- No active concentrations are disclosed anywhere; proprietary plant 'complexes' obscure what is actually present at what dose, making independent efficacy assessment impossible.
- At $270 for 60ml, formula-equivalent products using identical core actives (shea, squalane, glycerin, panthenol) are widely available for $15–$50.
- Jar packaging compromises antioxidant stability over a product's lifespan.
Budget Alternative
Weleda Skin Food Original Ultra-Rich Cream by Weleda — $18 (shea butter, plant extracts, rich emollient base delivering functionally equivalent moisturization without the luxury markup)
Score Breakdown
How Each AI Scored
AI Consensus
Strong agreement4 AI models independently scored this product, then cross-checked each other’s reasoning. Tap a model to see its take.
FAQ
What does Glow Index measure for Sisley-Paris Black Rose Cream Mask?
Glow Index evaluates non-medical skincare research signals: ingredient efficacy, safety profile, value for money, formula transparency, skin compatibility, and sensory usability.
Is this a medical recommendation?
No. Glow Index is not medical advice, not a diagnosis, and not a treatment recommendation. It is a consumer research layer for comparing skincare products and marketing claims.
Why does Glow Index use multiple AI models?
Multiple models reduce single-model bias. Glow Index surfaces consensus and disagreement instead of relying on one AI answer or brand marketing copy.